Guide
Roofing review requests: ask after the magnet sweep, not the tear-off
Ask a roofing customer for a review after the job is fully closed out: the crew is gone, the yard has been swept for nails, and the final walkthrough or inspection is done. For insurance jobs, wait until the claim money has settled. A review that comes in while the homeowner is still fighting a supplement goes badly. Send your direct Google review link with a request for a photo of the finished roof. Ask every customer, with no incentives.
Roofing timing is different
A roof is one of the largest checks a homeowner writes, and the job is weather-bound. The Bureau of Labor Statistics notes that roofers usually do not work during inclement weather, that work in northern states may be limited in winter, and that crews often work overtime in the busy summer months. Your reviews cluster where your jobs cluster.
Scroll horizontally to compare all columns. With the table focused, use the Left and Right arrow keys.
| Job | When to ask | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Full replacement, retail | 1 to 3 days after final cleanup | Nails in the driveway, gutter debris |
| Storm or hail job through insurance | After the final payment and depreciation are released | Open supplements, deductible questions |
| Leak repair | After the first good rain with no leak | Asking before rain proves nothing |
| Inspection or estimate only | Don't ask for a Google review yet | Follow up on the quote instead |
| Commercial or flat roof | After the owner's walkthrough | Ask the decision-maker, not the tenant |
The leak repair is the odd one out. A leak repair isn't proven until it rains. Text after the next storm: "Did it stay dry?" Then send the link.
What to send
Hi [first name], it's [company]. Your new roof is done and the crew swept the yard twice. If you're happy with it, a Google review, ideally with a photo of the house, helps neighbors find a roofer they can trust: [review link]
After a storm job:
Hi [first name], now that your claim's wrapped up, thank you for going through it with us. If we made it easier, a review would help other homeowners dealing with hail damage: [review link]
The rules
- Google forbids businesses that "selectively solicit positive reviews from customers".
- No discounts, gift cards or "we'll cover part of your deductible" for a review. Google's review guidelines prohibit incentives. Covering deductibles can also raise insurance problems of its own.
- The FTC rule bans incentives conditioned on a positive review.
Review tools, prices checked November 21, 2026
Scroll horizontally to compare all columns. With the table focused, use the Left and Right arrow keys.
| Option | What it does | Published price |
|---|---|---|
| NiceJob | Automatic review requests by text and email | Starter $95 a month, Pro $135 a month |
| Housecall Pro | Field service software, review tools included | Basic from $59 a month billed annually, $79 monthly |
| Podium | Text-based review requests | Quote only |
| Birdeye | Reviews, listings, messaging | Quote only (our review) |
| Your Google Business Profile link | Copy from "Get more reviews" | Free |
Roofing CRMs often include review requests too. Check what you already pay for before adding a tool.
Where TeamShift fits
TeamShift's Customer success worker drafts a review request when a job closes in your records. Insurance jobs can wait until you mark the claim settled, and leak repairs can wait for the next rain. Each text or email goes out only after you approve it. It also drafts replies to new reviews for your OK. Usage billing with a monthly cap (pricing).
Most roofing revenue starts as an estimate. The estimate follow-up templates cover the follow-up schedule, and roofing website design covers showing reviews where they convert.
FAQ
When should a roofer ask for a review on an insurance job?
After the claim is fully settled and paid. Asking mid-claim invites a review about the adjuster, not your crew.
Should I ask for photos?
Yes. A photo of a finished roof is proof of real work, and it helps the next homeowner picture their house.
Can I ask for a review after a free inspection?
You can, but most people haven't experienced enough to review. Focus on getting the job, then ask at closeout.
Sources
- The Bureau of Labor Statistics notes that roofers usually do not work during inclement weather, that work in northern states may be limited in winter, and that crews often work overtime in the busy summer months. (source)
- Google forbids businesses that "selectively solicit positive reviews from customers". (source)
- Google's review guidelines prohibit incentives. (source)
- The FTC rule bans incentives conditioned on a positive review. (source)
- NiceJob; Automatic review requests by text and email; Starter $95 a month, Pro $135 a month. (source)
- Housecall Pro; Field service software, review tools included; Basic from $59 a month billed annually, $79 monthly. (source)
- Podium; Text-based review requests; Quote only. (source)
- Birdeye; Reviews, listings, messaging; Quote only (our review). (source)